U.S. Regulators’ Reach into EMEA Firm
It turns out these words weren’t "all bark and no bite." For example, SEC v. Tiger Asia Management et al., involved a firm which was trading Chinese bank stocks executed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKSE). Tiger Asia allegedly submitted losing trades in securities of Chinese bank stocks on the HKSE, in order to manipulate the price, which artificially inflated the management fees. The SEC claimed it had jurisdiction since the sole principal of the firm resided in New Jersey, and placed and received telephone calls (related to the charges) from his residence. The HK Firm ultimately agreed to pay a combined 60 million USD in disgorgement and penalties, including 44 million USD to settle the SEC’s civil action and 16 million USD forfeited in connection with the criminal action.A few months later the SEC filed another case – SEC v. Certain Unknown Traders in the Securities of H.J. Heinz Company (yes, that is the ACTUAL name of the original complaint). Acting without knowledge of any material link to conduct within the United States, and without knowing the identities or nationalities of the traders involved, the SEC was able to affect an account freeze in Switzerland.These may sound like extreme examples but they are by no means outliers, and more importantly are illustrative of a very disturbing trend. As the securities environment becomes increasingly intertwined, and cross border trading becomes far more common, the SEC, and by extension the United States, may have designed a playbook for foreign regulators of competent jurisdictions to impose their will within the U.S. markets.MiFID II Turns the Table
In years past, the U.S. was shielded from such an unthinkable outcome. Matteo Winkler, professor of law at HEC Paris stated, "for companies to make money, they need to trade through the U.S. financial system. It is therefore a matter of global economic power. In addition, a key to understanding what makes the U.S. so influential is the use of dollars. The dollar is the main world currency and is dominant economically.” Having oversight for the security and stability of the largest financial system in the world, U.S. regulatory entities can certainly justify extreme measures. As a result some financial institutions in EMEA and APAC were forced to avoid trades and business decisions that ran afoul of DFA.But now, the EU is borrowing a page from the U.S. playbook.Today, MiFID II has everyone’s attention, in much the same way that Dodd-Frank did back in 2010. The EU regulation has been reported as "a bold new law that will reshape Europe’s capital markets," warning firms "the magnitude of this (sic) should not be underestimated." Although enforcement questions remain, a lot of guidance has been published and stern warnings issued for market participants not in compliance. Firms within the EU continue to prepare for the implementation date of 3 January 2018. Still, firms in the United States are by and large ignoring MiFID II altogether. If your firm is one of those taking a wait-and-see attitude, consider the following.Come January, the EU will have a regulation that is as large, complex, and as far reaching as Dodd-Frank. ESMA, the independent EU authority, has the capacity to issue guidance that competent authorities of member states have the ability to conduct investigations outside the EU. Taking a page from the U.S. playbook, ESMA could conceivably require any firms with substantial ties to the EU markets to comply with MiFID II. Using the collective size of the EU markets, the European Commission has all the leverage needed to force compliance. The adjusted GDP of the 28 EU member nations is larger than both China and the US. In an interview, Joseph P. Quinlan, chief market strategist for US Trust stated "in nominal U.S. dollar terms, the European Union (plus Norway, Switzerland, Iceland) accounted for 25.4% of world output in 2014 according to data from the International Monetary Fund." Should the EU decide to pursue this course of action, how many firms would be willing to endanger access to the largest collective economy in the world? Furthermore, diplomatically the United States would find itself hard pressed to defend actions that they themselves developed.
